Reviews For The Wishing Tree

You must login (register) to review.

Reviewer: Jayiin (Signed)
02/23/2009 02:43 am

When I first read this fic, I didn't understand the depth of your love for Neville, so I didn't grasp the significance of him giving them the tree.  Reading back over it, I see more layers and depth than I did when I first beta'd this story.

It's still a powerful read - well done!




The Wishing Tree
Reviewer: CrysCullen (Signed)
02/21/2009 08:07 pm

Adorable! You really are an amazing author... I must ask, though, what would Jack wish for??



Author's Response:

*grins* Thanks so much!

As for Jack and his wish, I'm not entirely sure. I think it would probably be something silly, almost "wasteful" (or so it might seem to someone who takes these things seriously), just because he's so young--and there might be consequences if he gets what he wishes for. I kind of hint at that when I mention Albus (that would be Albus Severus, not Dumbledore :P), who wished for ice cream and then ate himself sick on it. In my head (and therefore in my Wishing Tree Universe) the tree just knows there's a wish being made, and it doesn't judge whether it's a "good wish" or a "bad wish." And, I think, if a person wishes hard enough to invoke the magic, the Tree will grant the wish, even if maybe granting it isn't exactly the best thing that could happen.




The Wishing Tree
You must login (register) to review.