Reviews For Minerva Moves On

You must login (register) to review.

Reviewer: Madeline Fabray (Signed)
08/20/2006 01:16 pm
Wow, I've seen some stories concerning McGonagall and the aftermath of Dumbledore's death. Yours is the best I've read. You go so deep for such a short story. You feel her lack of confidence, the skeletons in her closet. But I love the show of McGonagall grit at the end, not to mention the fact that while Dumbledore may have been in a class by himself, McGonagall has her own strengths and has more talent and spunk at the end than she gives herself credit for.

Author's Response:

Thanks, Madeline.  *blushes*  Served up by a writer who's own depthful characterizations I much admire, this is real meat and drink for me. 

I do love Minerva though and feel that JKR short-shrifted an opportunity to ennoble her character in HBP (deliberately according to one interview)--which is the main reason I wrote this piece.




Chapter 1
Reviewer: YelloWitchGrl (Signed)
05/11/2006 03:12 pm
:-) A very interesting tale and turn around.  I had never looked at things quite that way.  Good job!



Chapter 1
Reviewer: Lizzie22153 (Signed)
05/10/2006 06:39 pm
Nice, very nice. I liked it. Well Written.


Chapter 1
You must login (register) to review.